Votre partenaire en Chine pour la fabrication de moules et le moulage par injection en source directe

Assistance mondiale · Réponse rapide · Spécialisé dans les équipementiers

Guide comparatif : moulage sous pression, usinage CNC et moulage par injection

usinage de l'aluminium par CNC

Die Casting vs CNC Machining vs Injection Molding: How to Choose the Right Process

Choosing between moulage sous pression de l'aluminium, CNC machining and injection molding is rarely about which process is best. It is about volume, geometry, funcation, material requirements and the tolerance you actually need to hold. A wrong choice shows up later as tooling that never pays back, porosity inside aluminum die casting part or at a sealing face, a plastic part that crarp or creeps under load. all of those you need to think about in advance.

moulage sous pression

This guide compares the three processes the way a manufacturing engineer would: process physics, material grades, achievable tolerances, tooling economics and design rules. Use it to shortlist a process before you request quotes.

Note: all figures below are typical industry ranges. Final capability depends on part geometry, alloy or resin, tooling and the supplier’s process control, so always confirm against your drawing.

Quick Answer: Which Process Fits Your Part?

Choose aluminum CNC machining for prototypes, low volumes (roughly 1 to 1,000 pieces), tight tolerances and fast lead time with no tooling.

Choose high pressure die casting for complex, thin-wall aluminum, zinc or magnesium housings at volumes typically above 5,000 to 10,000 pieces per year.

Choose injection molding when a thermoplastic meets the load, temperature and chemical requirements, especially from a few thousand to millions of injection molded parts. One of the best manufacturing process saving the unit cost.

Many production parts combine two processes, most often die casting followed by CNC finishing for some special tight tolerance.

How Each Process Works

High pressure die casting (HPDC). Molten aluminum, typically 660 to 700 °C for A380, is forced through a cold-chamber shot sleeve into a hardened steel die. Dies are usually H13 (1.2344) at roughly 44 to 48 HRC. Gate velocities of about 30 to 60 m/s fill the cavity in tens of milliseconds, then intensification pressure packs the casting as it solidifies. Clamp force ranges from a few hundred to several thousand tons, and cycles of 30 to 90 seconds are typical for small and medium parts.

CNC machining. A subtractive process: mills and lathes cut a part from bar, plate or a casting blank under a G-code program. In aluminum Usinage CNC, carbide tools at high spindle speeds (cutting speeds of several hundred m/min) are standard on 6061-T6 and 7075-T6. Repeatability depends on fixturing, work offsets (G54 to G59) and tool length offsets, so setup discipline matters as much as the machine.

Aluminum CNC machining

Injection molding. Dried thermoplastic pellets are melted by a reciprocating screw and injected into a mold, commonly P20 prehardened steel (about 28 to 40 HRC) or hardened H13 and 420 stainless for abrasive or corrosive resins. Packing pressure, mold temperature and cooling time control shrinkage and warpage. A common sizing rule is clamp tonnage of about 2 to 5 tons per square inch of projected area, depending on resin viscosity, plus a safety margin.

Plastic Injection Molding Manufacturer – One stop Manufacturing

Process Comparison at a Glance

FacteurHigh pressure die castingUsinage CNCMoulage par injection
Typical materialsAluminum (A380, ADC12, A360, A413), zinc (Zamak 2, 3, 5 8), magnesium (AZ91D)Most metals and engineering plasticsThermoplastics (ABS, PC, PA66, PP, ASA POM, PEEK/PEI)
Economic volumeAbout 5,000 to 10,000+1 to 1,000s1,000s to millions
OutillageHardened steel die (8418, 8407, S1.2343 ESR, etc), typically tens of thousands of USD or moreNone (fixtures only)Steel (P20, 718H, 1.2378HH, S136, NAK80, H13, 1.2344, etc) or aluminum mold
First partsTypically 8 to 16 weeksDaysTypically 4 to 12 weeks
As-produced toleranceAbout ±0.1 mm on small features- post CNC machining can reach -/+0.01mm±0.01 to ±0.05 mm standard±0.05 to ±0.2 mm, part size and resin dependent
Minimum wallAbout 1.0 to 1.5 mm (aluminum)About 0.5 to 0.8 mmAbout 0.5 to 1.0 mm
Surface (Ra)1.6 to 3.2 µm as cast, surface finish can be added according to requirement), such as anodizing, powder coating, E-coating, plating, etc)0.8 to 3.2 µm, finer with finishing, such as anodizing, powder coating, E-coating, plating, etc)Set by mold texture, EDM texture, VDI 3400 texture, SPI surface finish requirement, painting or plating can be added according to requriement
Unit cost at volumeFaibleHautLowest

Aluminum Die Casting vs Aluminum CNC Machining: Materials

The same part drawing does not give the same part in both processes, because the alloys differ.

AlliageProcessusDensité (g/cm³)UTS (MPa)Yield (MPa)ÉlongationThermal Conductivity (W/m·K)
A380 (as cast)HPDC2.74~320~160~3.5%~96
A360 (as cast)HPDC2.63~317~170~3.5%~113
A383 / ADC12HPDC2.74~310~150~3.5%~96
A413.0 / ADC1 / YL102HPDC2.66~296~145~2.5–3%~121
6061-T6CNC / Extrusion2.70~310~27612–17%~167
7075-T6CNC / Extrusion2.81~570~500~11%~130

Three practical consequences follow.

Ductility and fatigue. A380 has low elongation and contains gas and shrinkage porosity. Wrought 6061 and 7075 are fully dense, so they are the better choice for fatigue-critical or high-yield-strength parts.

Heat treatment. Conventional high pressure die casting is generally not solution treated, because entrapped gas can cause blistering. Vacuum-assisted HPDC reduces gas content and widens the options, but confirm this with your caster.

Finishing. A380 contains roughly 8 to 10.5% silicon and about 3 to 4% copper, which gives poor decorative anodizing. 6061 anodizes cleanly. If cosmetics matter, specify the finish early.

For the CNC side, published work on drilling Al-Mg-Si extrusions shows that alloy temper and microstructure change tool life, cutting force and burr height. Studies on turning 6061-T6 also found that surface roughness is governed mainly by feed rate rather than cutting speed. Plan feeds before chasing spindle speed.

Injection Molding: Where Injection Molded Parts Beat Metal

Injection molded parts win when weight, cost at volume, electrical insulation, corrosion resistance or integrated features (snap fits, living hinges, bosses) matter more than stiffness or heat conduction.

Plastic Injection Molding Materials & Typical Shrinkage Rates

ResinTypical ShrinkageUtilisation typique
ABS0.4–0.7%Housings, consumer enclosures
PC0.5–0.7%Transparent covers, impact parts
PC/ABS0.4–0.7%Automotive interiors, electronic housings
PA66-GF300.3–0.8% (anisotropic)Structural parts, under-hood components, wheels,
POM1.8–2.2%Gears, precision sliding parts
PP1.0–2.5%Living hinges, chemical resistance
PVC (Rigid)0.2–0.6%Pipes, fittings, electrical enclosures
COUP D'OEIL0.9–1.5%Aerospace, medical, high-temperature components
PEI (Ultem)0.5–0.8%Electrical connectors, aerospace, medical components
PPS0.6–1.4%Automotive components, electrical insulation, pump parts
PPSU0.4–0.7%Medical devices, sterilizable components, fluid handling
PPE / PPO0.5–0.7%Electrical housings, automotive components
PS (GPPS)0.3–0.7%Transparent containers, packaging, consumer products
PEHD1.5–4.0%Containers, tanks, industrial piping
ASA0.4–0.7%Outdoor enclosures, automotive exterior parts,
PMMA (Acrylique)0.2–0.6%Optical lenses, light covers, transparent components

Shrinkage differs between the flow and cross-flow directions, particularly in glass-filled grades, and warpage follows. Verify with the resin supplier’s data sheet and mold-flow analysis before cutting steel.

When volumes are modest, 7075 aluminum molds can cut tooling lead time and cycle time because aluminum conducts heat far better than steel. Steel remains the standard for high volumes and abrasive resins.

Design Rules That Change the Process Decision

RuleHigh pressure die castingUsinage CNCMoulage par injection
Épaisseur de la paroiUniform, about 1.5 to 4 mmDown to about 0.8 mm; thin walls vibrateAs thin as practical, uniform, often 0.2 to 3 mm
DraftAbout 1 to 3°None requiredAbout 0.25 to 2°, more with texture
RayonsGenerous fillets, avoid sharp cornersInternal radius set by cutter diameterInside radius around 0.5× wall is common practice
RibsAt or below adjacent wall thicknessLimited by tool reachAbout 50 to 60% of wall to avoid sink marks
Contre-dépouillesSlides and cores add tooling costReachable with 4th or 5th axisSlides and lifters add tooling cost
Machining stockAbout 0.3 to 0.8 mm on critical facesNot applicableNot applicable

Uniform wall thickness is the shared rule. In molding, walls above roughly 2 to 2.5 mm can lengthen cycle time sharply, because cooling time scales with the square of thickness. In die casting, thick sections trap shrinkage porosity.

usinage de l'aluminium par CNC

Cost and Volume Break-Even

Unit cost is tooling amortization plus cycle cost plus secondary operations.

CNC machining has near-zero tooling but a high and nearly constant cost per part, driven by machine time, setup and material removed. A part cut from billet that removes 80% of the stock pays for that waste on every piece.

High pressure die casting and injection molding carry significant tooling investment but low marginal cost. The break-even point depends on part size, cavity count and secondary operations, so ask for quotes at three volume tiers (for example 1,000, 10,000 and 100,000 pieces a year) and compare total landed cost.

Do not forget hidden items: first-article inspection, gauges, X-ray or leak testing on pressure-tight castings, deburring and surface treatment.

The Hybrid Route: Die Casting Plus CNC

Most production aluminum die casting parts are not shipped as cast. Sealing faces, bearing bores, threads and tight-position features are machined after casting.

Keys to making it work:

  • Define datums on the casting so the die caster and machinist locate from the same features.
  • Leave machining stock on critical faces and avoid removing the dense skin where you can.
  • Use vacuum-assisted HPDC and inspection (X-ray, density or leak testing) for pressure-tight parts, since machining can open subsurface porosity.
  • Use carbide or PCD tooling on A380, because its silicon content is abrasive.

This approach captures the low unit cost of casting and the tolerance of machining.

Decision Checklist

  1. Volume per year and total program life.
  2. Required material properties: strength, fatigue, thermal conductivity, weight, chemical exposure.
  3. Tightest tolerance and its location on the part.
  4. Wall thickness and geometry complexity.
  5. Surface finish and cosmetic requirements.
  6. Lead time to first article versus time to production.
  7. Quality requirements: PPAP or equivalent, leak testing, traceability.

FAQ

Is aluminum die casting cheaper than CNC machining? At sufficient volume, yes, because the unit cost of high pressure die casting is far lower. At low volume, die tooling cost makes CNC machining cheaper.

Can die cast aluminum match the strength of CNC machined aluminum? Not generally. A380 has lower elongation and has porosity risk. For fatigue-critical parts, wrought 6061-T6 or 7075-T6 is usually the safer choice. but if you need more strong aluminum part, gravity die casting maybe another option.

When should I choose injection molding over aluminum? When a plastic meets the structural and thermal requirements and volume justifies the mold. Injection molded parts are lighter, insulating and cheaper per piece at scale.

What tolerances can each process hold? Typically ±0.01 to ±0.05 mm for CNC, about ±0.1 mm on small as-cast die casting features, and ±0.05 to ±0.2 mm for injection molding depending on resin. Always check against the drawing and supplier capability data.

Can I prototype with CNC and then switch to die casting? Yes, but expect differences. The alloy changes (6061 to A380), draft and fillets must be added, and porosity can affect machined surfaces. Involve the caster before design freeze.

Does a moulage sous pression always need machining? No, but features like threads, bores and sealing faces usually do.

Partager :

Elementor : article unique #12883

Mike Zheng

Mike Zheng est un ingénieur qui possède plus de 10 ans d'expérience dans la fabrication de moules. Si vous avez un projet et que vous ne savez pas s'il se prête à la fabrication de moules, ou si vous souhaitez obtenir un devis, n'hésitez pas à le contacter : il examinera vos données et vous proposera un devis dans les 24 heures.

Table des matières

Plus d'articles

Envoyez-nous un message

Articles similaires

Défiler vers le haut